1. Reputation & Support
| Feature |
Alia |
Poptin |
| User Ratings |
4.9/5 (100+ reviews on Shopify App Store) |
4.9/5 (300 reviews on Shopify App Store) |
| Common Praise Points |
"Actually works" simplicity; fast ROI (days not months); genuine education-first approach; white-glove support; "set it and forget it" AI optimization |
Simple, intuitive setup; effective exit-intent popups; flexible customization; fast, hands-on support; smooth Shopify integration |
| Support Channels |
White-glove onboarding, live chat, Slack channel access, and a dedicated Customer Success Manager (CSM) who acts like "part of the team." |
Fast and responsive customer support; easy onboarding; standard support on lower tiers |
| User Critiques |
Shopify-exclusive platform; catered toward established brands rather than early-stage stores |
Setup quirks and minor bugs; limited wheel features; some learning curve; support varies on busy days; free plan restrictions |
| Onboarding Experience |
Hands-on setup assistance included for all users to ensure proper implementation from day one |
Standard setup support; dedicated onboarding manager only available on the Business plan |
| Retention & Migration |
High stickiness with 3-5x ROI reported long-term. Heavy inflow of users switching from Klaviyo, Privy, and Justuno seeking better conversion without discounts. |
Good retention for multi-campaign reliance; agencies and SaaS companies adopting it for email capture |
Poptin earns praise for its easy setup and flexible customization, making it a reliable tool for small teams that value simplicity. While it offers responsive support, the level of guidance varies by tier, and users occasionally note minor bugs or feature limits on the free plan.
Alia, on the other hand, stands out by acting as a partner rather than just a tool. It is highly rated for its "white-glove" experience, providing every user with a dedicated CSM and Slack access.
For brands that want a "set it and forget it" model where the support team helps drive strategy and performance—rather than just troubleshooting—Alia’s high-touch model offers significantly more long-term value.
"The customer support/team provided the level of service and timely
responses you would expect of a
5-star resort."
—Urban Smokehouse team
2. Design, Templates, & Performance
| Feature |
Alia |
Poptin |
| Template Library |
100+ production-ready, conversion-focused templates designed for storytelling and education. |
Wide selection of fully responsive popup and form templates across many formats (bars, lightbox, fullscreen, gamified). |
| Site Speed Impact |
Zero-lag loading. Built specifically for Shopify to load instantly without slowing down store performance. |
Mobile responsive design; optimized for fast loading across platforms via a lightweight script. |
| Customization Options |
Custom fonts, code, translation, localization and advanced triggers for Shopify stores. |
Drag-and-drop editor with multiple popup types and forms; includes targeting rules (page, device, geo, audience). |
| Mobile Experience |
Popup templates and new projects are desktop, tablet, and mobile-friendly by default. |
Fully responsive and mobile-optimized across all devices. |
| Analytics & tracking |
Conversion-focused analytics that track revenue impact and performance lift. |
Visual stats for visitors, views, and conversion rates; includes campaign-level tracking of clicks and traffic flow. |
Poptin delivers a clean drag-and-drop interface and broad template variety that helps brands launch popups quickly across multiple platforms. It is ideal for teams seeking flexibility and fast execution across various popup formats.
Alia offers a Shopify-native experience with zero-lag loading and templates focused on storytelling and performance. It is designed for merchants who treat popups as a revenue channel with creative offers (i.e., “scratch-to-win” and “mystery box” discounts), ensuring that mobile-friendly, interactive elements never compromise site speed.
Nakie saw 600% improvement in email capture and $5.8M in sales after switching to Alia
35%
PEAK EMAIL OPT-IN RATE (UP FROM 5-6%)
600%
IMPROVEMENT IN EMAIL CAPTURE
$5.8M
IN ATTRIBUTED SALES
Dean Leibbrandt
Co-Founder of Nakie
“
"We always cared about the customer journey, and Alia's the first tool that actually let us design one that makes sense. And once we did, everything clicked — sign-up rates, conversions, the whole funnel started significantly performing. Since switching to Alia, our lowest sign-up rate has been 28%, and we've even reached 35% in some months."
2
Launch first popup in 5 minutes
3) Automation & AI features
| Feature |
Alia |
Poptin |
| Testing & Variants |
Automated A/B testing. AI generates and tests multiple popup variants, automatically shifting traffic to the winner. |
Manual & AI-Assisted. Supports manual A/B testing, but also provides reports on best/worst performers to help users optimize results. |
| Smart Triggers |
AI-Powered. System learns from traffic and behavior to trigger popups at the exact moment a user is most likely to convert. |
Autopilot Trigger. AI-driven feature that learns visitor behavior and pinpoints the best time of day/moment to show popups. |
| Optimization Model |
Self-Improving. Continuous learning loop that optimizes content and popup timing without manual intervention. |
Semi-Autonomous. Uses machine learning to run tests and learn behavior, reducing the need for users to perform all their own A/B tests. |
| Content Intelligence |
Optimizes for brand story and conversion (zero-party data capture) rather than just discount codes. |
Focuses on optimizing timing and triggers via AI to help users who don't have time for manual management. |
Poptin enlists AI through its Autopilot Trigger to pinpoint the best timing for popups based on visitor behavior. It performs tests and provides reports on best/worst performers, offering a helpful alternative for those who don't have time to run every A/B test manually.
Alia uses an AI-powered, self-improving loop to handle testing, targeting, and timing automatically. It is designed to optimize for brand story and conversion through zero-party data capture without requiring manual intervention.
"
Alia gave us the power to A/B test everything…
Personalized triggers made popups feel more relevant and less intrusive… Access to conversion, AOV, and orders data has made decision-making so much faster.
Andrea Haynes
Retention Marketing Manager at Portland Leather
4) Data Collection & Integrations
| Feature |
Alia |
Poptin |
| Data Collection |
Zero-party data capture. Uses mini-quizzes and interactive flows to capture customer preferences (shopping goals, interests) alongside capturing emails. |
Behavioral capture. Displays popups based on user actions like scroll, timing, and pages visited. |
| Targeting Precision |
AI-Predicted. Targets based on behavioral cues and predicted intent, plus standard page/geo rules. |
Advanced rule-based targeting. Focuses on traffic source, geography, date/time, page URL, and new vs. returning visitors. |
| ESP/SMS Platforms |
Supports Klaviyo, Yotpo, Attentive, Omnisend, Sendlane, One Text, Contlo. |
Integrates with many platforms including Mailchimp, HubSpot, Klaviyo, and ActiveCampaign. |
| Analytics & Tools |
Yotpo, Ground AI, Black Crow AI, Fermat. |
Integrates with CRMs and many external platforms (via Zapier/Make) for analytics and lead flows. |
| Visitor Management |
Smart Suppression. Recognizes existing subscribers (via cookies/ESP data) to prevent annoying popup spam. |
Manual control. Uses frequency settings and visitor targeting options. |
| Best For |
Shopify brands prioritizing zero-party data, deep native integrations, and education-led signup flows. |
Multi-platform businesses needing extensive connectivity options and manual control over targeting. |
Poptin is a multi-platform tool best for brands needing manual control and broad connectivity across various CRMs; however, the tradeoff is that it lacks Alia’s automated intelligence, requiring you to exchange AI-driven optimization for granular manual rules and cross-platform flexibility. While Poptin offers advanced rule-based targeting for any website, it doesn't provide the same "set-it-and-forget-it" ease found in Shopify-specific tools. (If the manual rule management and lack of automated intelligence feel limiting, we've compiled a list of the top Poptin alternatives worth considering.)
Alia is a Shopify-native powerhouse built for zero-party data capture via interactive quizzes and educational flows. It leverages AI-predicted targeting and Smart Suppression to eliminate "popup spam," ensuring instant load speeds and native analytics that integrate data directly into your store's everyday operations.
"
"Alia has helped us gather richer, more actionable data by making it easier to capture customer intent in real time."
“We use it to collect customer-specific data, which helps us deliver more personalized product recommendations for each individual shopper.”
5) Pricing & scalability
| Feature |
Alia Popups |
Poptin |
| Pricing Model |
Plans start at US $100/month (up to 20k visitors). |
Visitor-based pricing starting at $25/month for 10,000 visitors. |
| Trial Options |
14-day free trial with full feature access. |
Free plan (1,000 monthly visitors) with basic features. |
| Usage Limits |
Pricing based on monthly unique visitors; higher tiers available. |
Visitor/pageview-based limits; tiered by visitor count and feature access. |
| Best For |
Shopify merchants wanting predictable, all-in-one pricing. |
Budget-conscious businesses needing an affordable entry point. |
Poptin offers an affordable entry point with plans starting at $25/month and a basic free tier, making it appealing for early-stage or budget-conscious users. However, pricing scales quickly with traffic and features, meaning costs can rise as brands grow.
Alia, though starting higher at $100/month, gives full-feature access upfront—no hidden tiers or locked tools. It’s a predictable, all-in-one pricing model built for Shopify merchants who prefer value and performance over constant upsells.
.svg)
.webp)